By analyzing and evaluating the entire experimental process, the author draws some
of the following conclusions:
Firstly, after the pedagogical impact, the reading comprehension skills of students
in experimental groups have been raised one step from the initial level and higher
than that of the general groups. This is evident in dealing with test questions and in
the course of learning some of the legend genre reading lessons. It can be said that
the students in the experimental groups and classes have initially achieved the goals
and basic requirements set by the author.
Secondly, the method of teaching reading comprehension of legend genre for grade 6
students in junior high school that the thesis proposed has been verified and shows
certain reliability. Although the experiment time is not much, but in the experimental
teaching process, students have been focused on building the skills of reading
comprehension of the legend by appropriate and positive impact measures
25 trang |
Chia sẻ: honganh20 | Ngày: 08/03/2022 | Lượt xem: 365 | Lượt tải: 0
Bạn đang xem trước 20 trang tài liệu Training the reading comprehension skills of legend genre for students in grade 6, để xem tài liệu hoàn chỉnh bạn click vào nút DOWNLOAD ở trên
us
authors, on the one hand, we inherit and develop PISA reading comprehension
levels, and the required requirements for reading comprehension of literary
texts of the General Education Program in Vietnamese Literature 2018, we
outline reading comprehension skills that need to be trained for students in high
schools as follows::
2.3. Some principles of teaching reading comprehension in Literature in
the direction of capacity development
2.3.1. Ensure the required requirements of the subject program
Requirement of the program is the concretization of the subject's objectives. So
it is imperative, a measure of the outcome of learning. That is why it is very
important and should be considered the first principle.On the basis of the
knowledge and skills requirements of the current Literature General Education
Program (2006), combined with the required requirements of the Literature
Program 2018 to generalize the reading comprehension skills of literary texts,
including: reading comprehension, reading comprehension form, reading
comprehension, connection extended beyond text.
R
ea
d
in
g
co
m
p
re
h
en
si
o
n
sk
ill
o
f
Le
ge
n
d
ge
n
re
st
o
ri
es
(1) Recognize facts, characters, details, plot ... in stories and factors related to historical truth
(2) Analyze the content value and art form of the legend story
(3) Comment, evaluate the attitude of the narrator (people) in the legend
(4) Related to historical context, personal experience to draw lessons and current value of the legend
9
2.3.2. Sticking to the text of reading comprehension, in teaching reading
comprehension with "alternate version"
In teaching reading comprehension, students must work directly with the text
under the guidance and support of teachers. Children must be guided to read
and read by their own abilities, thoughts and feelings, not by the thoughts and
feelings of the teacher.
2.3.3. Emphasize general and specific characteristics of type of document
Focusing closely on the characteristics of the genre in the process of guiding
students to read and understand text is a premise to teach students how to read,
reading skills. Through clusters of text of the same category arranged into a
topic, teachers will help students discover the value of content, art, and thought
of each text while forming and developing reading comprehension skills to be
able to actively conquer the value of new documents of the same category.
2.3.4. Associate the organization of reading comprehension teaching
activities with innovation oriented assessment of students' competency
development
We define the central content of evaluating the reading comprehension skills of
students in grade 6 in the direction of developing their competencies:
(1) Read the content value of the legend
- Remember the characters of the story
- Get to know key details / facts
- Be aware of the core historical factors involved
- Stating the topic, message of the story
- Summary of the main plot / content of the story based on the three-stage
structure of the legend
- Explaining the value of the content of the legend through the plot, title,
character, and incident
- Present your thoughts about the storyline, characters, and meaning of the story.
(2) Reading comprehension of legend art form
- Recognize magical factors, historical core
- Point out the effects of magical factors, historical core on the meaning of the
story
- Get comments on storylines, characters, storytellers and other artistic elements
- Explaining the artistic value of the legend through language, fantasy details,
space time factor of the story.
3) Read connection to compare, contact application
- Giving lessons about the individual's thinking and behavior prompted by the
legend.
10
- Compare a highlight between legends / folk tales / modern stories, ...
- Connecting a problem posed in legend with reality (history, society, local
culture,)
2.4. Teaching reading comprehension towards capacity development
2.4.1. General requirements
The first is to promote student activeness.
The second is integrated and differentiated teaching.
The third is to diversify teaching methods, techniques, forms of organization
and means.
2.4.2. Specific requirements of the method of teaching text reading
comprehension
Inheriting the research results of the previous authors, we found that with
readers in general and readers - students in schools in particular, reading
comprehension skills (in general) and associated with characteristic of literary
writing style (in particular) will consist of a series of reader's actions arranged
in a certain structure or order. Detail:
a. To perform reading comprehension, first, students need to know how to
perform actions as a premise for reading comprehension: reading silently,
skimming, scanning.
b. Followed by the actions of remembering and identifying information. To
perform this action, students must undergo one or more of the following actions:
repeating textual information, repeating information verbally different from
text, filling in text information in the blanks, select information in the text in the
confusing context.
c. Next is the act of understanding the meaning of the text. This type of action
is performed by manipulations: understanding the meaning of the word,
understanding the explicit and implicit meaning of the information, explaining,
interpreting, classifying, connecting, comparing information, being able to
grasp get the main idea of the paragraph in the text, outline textual culture,
understand the relationship between information in the text, state the artistic
tricks to create the meaning of the literary text.
d. After the text-understanding action, it will be the action of applying the text
to the tasks to change the perception, emotion, and opinion of the reader. This
action is also known as low-level text manipulation. The action of applying low-
level text is done by manipulating: giving the reader's personal opinion about
some information in the text, extracting information from the details in the text,
use the information in the text to practice simple problem solving similar to the
problem stated in the text
11
e. Text response action takes place on the basis of text comprehension. To
perform text feedback, students need to perform actions: linking information in
the text with their experiences, with the things they are interested in; Give
comments on the reliability of the text, make comments on the necessity of the
text content with the learning tasks they are doing, with their own experiences
in life.
2.4.3. Requires formation and practice of reading comprehension skills of
legend genre
To apply specifically to the formation and practice of reading comprehension
skills, it is necessary to establish a process of teaching reading comprehension
with scientific basis. Firstly, learners also need to work through and practice;
directly make products; Secondly, learners have to do it over and over again;
have to practice a lot; Thirdly, it should be combined with test and evaluation
to continue to consolidate and complete reading comprehension skills.
3. PRACTICAL BASIS
3.1. Grade 6 curriculum and textbooks with the practice of legend genre
reading comprehension skills for students
3.1.1. Current Literature Program requirements for teaching the legend
genre
- Understand and able to feel the main features of the content and art of some
typical Vietnamese legends (Mountain Spirit and Water Spirit; Thanh Giong;
Children of the Dragon, Grandchildren of the Immortal; The tales of Banh
chung and Banh giay; The Legend of Hoan Kiem Lake): reflect the reality of
life, the history of the struggle to build and retain the country, the desire to
conquer nature, the use of mythical and magical elements.
- Remember the plot, characters, events, some typical artistic details and the
meaning of each story: explanation of the origin of the race (Children of the
Dragon, Grandchildren of the Immortal); explain natural and social phenomena
(Mountain Spirit and Water Spirit; The tales of Banh chung and Banh giay);
aspiration for independence and peace (Thanh Giong; The Legend of Hoan
Kiem Lake).
- Recognizing art uses mythical elements, the relationship between mythical
elements and historical truth.
3.1.2. Content of reading comprehension training of legends of textbooks and
books for teachers of grade 6 Literature
In the current grade 6 Literature textbook, students can learn 5 texts arranged in
clusters of categories. Questions in Grade 6 Literature Textbook have focused
on training students in reading skills to remember characters and events,
12
summarize the story, understand the content and art of the story. However, the
questions have not focused on forging students skills to explain the content
values, the art of the legend closely adheres to the basic characteristics of the
genre; has not paid attention to the questions to connect and expand the
problems posed in the text. This also causes certain limitations in forming
students' reading comprehension skills.
3.2. Survey the current situation of teaching reading comprehension of
legend genre in grade 6
Nguyen Van To Junior High School, Hau Giang Junior High School, Viet My
Junior High School, Le Quy Don Junior High School, Chu Van An Junior High
School, Nguyen Van To Junior High School, Le Anh Xuan Junior High School,
Phu Tho High School, and Lu Gia Junior High School District 11 in Ho Chi
Minh City Minh and 239 students of 7 grade 6, at the two schools mentioned
above (Nguyen Van To Junior High School - District 10), Hau Giang Junior
High School.
The survey is conducted in combination by the following forms: using
questionnaires, attending lesson time, learning lesson plans, exchanging,
chatting, directly interviewing of teachers and students in order to find out the
current state of teaching reading comprehension of legend genre for students in
grade 6. On that basis, there are specific orientations on how to practice reading
comprehension skills of legend genre in order to contribute to developing
students' capacity which will be deployed in chapter 2. The survey process focus
on the following main contents:
(1) Survey lesson plans of teachers teaching reading comprehension and
practicing reading comprehension skills of legend genre.
(2) Types of questions for training text reading comprehension skills are used
by teachers in teaching hours of reading comprehension in three aspects
(reading comprehension of content; reading comprehension of art forms; related
reading, applying, connecting with reality) and the quality of questions used in
lessons (relevance, ability to attract, effect in the formation of reading
comprehension practice by genre)
Survey results are specifically as follows:
3.2.1. Survey lesson plans of teachers teaching reading comprehension of
legend genre
In general, the lesson plans are the same in how to demonstrate the teaching
process with three basic stages. However, the way of designing teaching content
has some differences. The question system in the lesson plans is mainly built to
exploit specific aspects of content and art of the text, almost absent the
13
generalized question of instrumental nature to form reading comprehension
skills of text by genre for students.
3.2.2. Types of questions and quality of questions in reading
comprehension skills are used in class
3.2.2.1. About types of questions to practice reading comprehension skills
used in class
It can be said that the types of questions used in teaching reading comprehension
in grade 6 are relatively rich. Some teachers have initially boldly experimented
with new questions that are not in the textbooks but stick with the teaching
orientation of capacity development. But most teachers still depend on the
system of teaching guiding questions in current textbooks. The training of text
reading comprehension skills by category is perceived correctly by most
teachers, but there are still significant gaps from awareness to action. Teachers
are still confused when explaining the effectiveness of the system of reading
comprehension guide questions that they themselves use. Students are still
confused about how to solve the system of learning instruction questions.
3.2.2.2. About the quality of the question system for training reading
comprehension skills used in class
Survey results from students show that many questions are still difficult
compared to the level of the majority of students; 328/339 students surveyed
(accounting for 96.7%) agreed with this statement. Commenting on the novelty
of the question system used by teachers in teaching and reading, there are
321/339 students surveyed (accounting for 94.6%) that the question system that
teachers use is question system in textbooks. Up to 187 students being consulted
(accounting for 55.1%) disagree when they think that many questions used by
teachers in class are capable of stimulating creativity in students. Regarding the
readiness level to read and understand other documents of the same genre, there
are 213 students (accounting for 62.8%) that they are not really confident; only
31 students (9.1%) confirmed their confidence level; This rate in the quite
confident group is 43 students (accounting for 12.7%). And when dealing with
five required requirements of the legend genre reading comprehension skills
(mentioned in the theoretical basis), there are only 102 students (accounting for
30.1%) self-evaluate themselves at the level of confidence and quite confident
in solving these requirements.
Results of the survey of 88 teachers on some limitations of the question system
for training reading comprehension skills used in basic lessons showed similar
results with the comments of the group of students. However, the majority of
teachers (51/88) surveyed agree that the question system when using reading
14
comprehension has not focused on guiding students to read. Up to 59.1% of
teachers (52/88) admit that the question system in the lessons is less new,
mainly questions in textbooks and 53.4% of teachers (47/88) stated that quite a
few questions are difficult compared to grade 6 students.
CONCLUSION OF CHAPTER 1
In chapter 1, we have clarified the theoretical and practical basis of the problem
of forging reading comprehension skills for students in grade 6. It can be seen
that teaching reading comprehension by genre characteristics is in the right
direction and with the right scientific basis. However, the teaching of reading
comprehension in junior high schools has not achieved high results; the matter
of training the legend genre reading comprehension skill for the students of the
teachers was not truly effective; The students were not able to fully undersood
the value of the legend genre texts in the text book's program, they are yet to
possess the skill of reading comprehension of legend genre.
CHAPTER 2: THE TRAINING METHODS OF LEGEND GENRE
READING COMPREHENSION SKILL FOR GRADE 6 STUDENT
1. Some general requirements
1.1. Organizing teaching through activities
Turn the activities of students become more active in teaching reading
comprehension means: During Literature hours, teachers do not read for them,
not understand the lesson for them, not impose their understanding for students,
but organize and guide students to find ways to approach and decode, able to
read and comprehen of the text, helping students know how to listen, speak,
read, write, enjoy literature.
1.2. Stick to category characteristics
The methods of teaching reading comprehension of the legend must adhere to
the characteristics of the genre as presented in the previous chapter. For junior
high school students, we emphasize three basic characteristics of the legend that
teachers should pay attention to in the process of guiding students to read and
understand texts. At the same time, when instructing students to read and
understand the legends, the teacher should also encourage them to compare the
variations associated with the text with historical and local contexts to realize
the features of the legend.
1.3. Ensure fitting of students' capability
To ensure the fitting of students' capability, teachers must pay special attention
to implementing differentiated teaching, not assigning equal tasks to students,
but based on the capacity of each group to move towards their "near
development area".
15
1.4. Meeting the requirements of forming skills in reading comprehension of
legendary stories
Legend is a genre of folk tales, a literary form of text that has its own distinctive
characteristics. Therefore, the specific goal of teaching legend lessons helps
students discover the specific beauty of a particular legend and form reading
comprehension skills of this genre. First of all, it is necessary to ensure the
requirements of teaching reading comprehension of literary texts and then
ensure the requirement of reading comprehension of the text according to the
characteristics of the legend genre.
1.5. Diversity in teaching organizing
The selection of teaching methods, techniques, forms of organization in
accordance with teaching content and student's audience is important to achieve
new goals. The diversity of requirements of learning tasks also contributes to
students' excitement when performing, improving learning quality.
2. How to form and practice reading comprehension skills of legend genre
Outline the process of forming and practicing reading comprehension skills
The steps Yêu cầu Hình thức
1. Forming
knowledge and
reading
comprehension
skill
a) Recognize factors related to
historical facts (stories, events,
characters)
b) Content and form value analysis
(plot, characters, mythical, fantasy
details)
c) Comment and evaluate the
attitudes of the narrator;
d) Contact to draw lessons of topical
value of the legendary text
- Teachers
organize and
guide students
in reading
comprehension
skills through a
specific text.
2. Practice
training
Focus on the four requirements of
step 1, but to a different extent.
Students do it mainly.
- Students
perform
reading
comprehension
in class with the
help of teachers
Stick to the requirements formed and
practiced in the first 2 steps.
- Students
read and
16
3. Practice
reinforcement
present their
results in class
by themselves.
4. Evaluating
examination
Adhering to the requirements that
have been formed and trained to set
out, check reading results.
- Students
perform their
tests
2.1. Forming skills of reading comprehension of legendary stories through
teaching activities.
2.1.1. Form skills to recognize characters, events, details, storylines and factors
related to historical truths of legends
Legend belongs to the category of folk tales, so the character in the legend is a
highlight to pay attention to when teaching text reading comprehension. The
life of the main character in legends is often presented in three stages.
Besides the character, the incident is also a characteristic aspect of the textual
content of the narrative genre. The literary theory affirms that the story is a
series of events that happen consecutively for the character in space and time,
with the beginning, the development and the end to show relationships,
contradictions to reflect a certain progress in character's life. The organization
of events is the way to create the plot for a literary work. Accurately identify
the typical events of the story will help readers grasp the story more easily.
One of the typical characteristics of the legend is also the appearance of magical
and mythical details with profound symbolic meanings. However, with grade 6
students, especially with the first lesson in the series of legends, teachers can
just stop at the request to identify details of fanciful fantasy and initially state
the meaning of those details with showing the content of the story and effect on
the reader.
2.1.2. Form skills to analyze the content value and art form of the legend story
This skill will, basically, put on higher requirements than the first skill. Analysis
of the content value and artistic form of a legend firstly aims to read and
understand in detail the elements of the story, then generalize, comment /
evaluate the value of the work. These are also tasks aimed at the reading
comprehension requirement of the textual art form and content of the Literature
Program 2018. In PISA's opinion, this question group is in the task of analyzing
and explain the information, requires thinking mainly is applying, besides
still need questions at cognitive level. Because it is the first lesson aimed at
forming legend reading comprehension skills, for difficult questions,
17
teachers need specific instructions and suggestions to help students think step
by step to get the correct answers.
2.1.3. Forming skills of commenting and evaluating the attitudes of the narrator
(people) in the legend
In order for students to form this skill, teachers need to emphasize when talking
about the characteristics of legends. Research results on folklore have shown
that in each legend, we not only find there the spirit of fighting against foreign
aggression and natural disasters, but also many lessons about the way of life,
the view of human life, about customs and habits, social relations, and practices
of production and its usage,
2.1.4. Develop skills related to historical context, personal experience to draw
lessons about current value of the legend
In order for students to know the relationship with the historical context,
mobilize personal experiences to draw lessons and current value of the legend,
when teaching each specific text, the teacher should choose some typical details
to guide students to think and comment in order to create their deep reading
habits. Or find problems that relate the text to real life.
2.2. Practice reading comprehension skills of legend stories through guided
practice activities
2.2.1. Guided practice reinforces character recognition, facts, details,
storylines, ... and other factors related to historical facts..
In order to reinforce this reading comprehension skill in students, the questions
about characters, events, details, storylines, and elements related to historical
facts continue to be repeated as in activities that forming the skill. Doing so will
create "grooves" in students' thinking; Students will understand that, in order to
read and understand the legend, first of all, you need to remember and explain
about those factors.
2.2.2. Guided practice reinforces the skills of analyzing the content value and
art form of a legend story
In practice activities with instructions so that students know to analyze the
content value and artistic form of the legend stories, the teacher continues to
give a system of questions and exercises that require students to explain the
content value of the legend text through the title, storyline; typical details,;
explains the artistic value of the legend through language, fantasy details,
storytellers' words, the time and space elements of the story. This skill students
have gained from formative activities, here repeats and is at a higher level.
2.2.3. Guided practice reinforces the emotional awareness skills and attitudes
of the narrator (the people) in the legend
18
In order to reinforce the skill of commenting and assessing people's attitudes
towards events and characters that being told in guided reading comprehension
practice, teachers continue to design similar learning tasks as in skill formation
activity, to help students can once again perform those tasks - but illuminate
another legendary text. The questions and exercises to guide students to practice
this skill can be basically repeated as forming activities.
2.2.4. Guided practice reinforces the skill of relating to historical contexts,
personal experience to draw lessons and topical value of a legend story
In guided practice activities, teachers can expand and engrave more deeply on
two key issues expressing the content and meaning of folk legends.
Understanding issues related to the historical context of the legends will help
students recognize ideological lessons and profound current value of the
legends..
2.3.
Các file đính kèm theo tài liệu này:
- training_the_reading_comprehension_skills_of_legend_genre_fo.pdf